The Impossible Disappearance Of Dorothy Arnold

  • Published: 27 September 2019
  • A special bonus episode of True Crime!

    A 25-year-old socialite goes missing off the streets of New York City in 1910. Did she run away…or was it something worse? Don't miss Nancy Drew. Premiering October 9th at 9/8c on The CW.


    Licensed via Audio Network

    Welcome to the BuzzFeed Unsolved Network! This channel is your one-stop destination for all things mystery, conspiracy, supernatural, true crime, and everything in between. Subscribe here: and get the official merch here:

    Antique photo: "Tantallon Castle" ship
    ilbusca/Getty Images
    A floral coin purse
    Agustin Vai/Getty Images
    View through a porthole on a stormy sea with waves hitting the ship
    Sjo/Getty Images
    Brick wall
    themacx/Getty Images
    Business people, group of men and women isolated silhouettes
    msan10/Getty Images
    Fire from the furnace
    ?????? ???????/Getty Images
    Edward VII and Queen Alexandra, as Prince and Princess of Wales
    duncan1890/Getty Images
    Vintage thank you note
    THEPALMER/Getty Images
    John Morley, 1st Viscount Morley of Blackburn, 1890s
    duncan1890/Getty Images
    Elegant rectangular frame with herbs and leaves. Golden luxury wedding design. Vector isolated illustration.
    Anatartan/Getty Images
    Subway Car Isolated
    Nerthuz/Getty Images
    Lord Salisbury, British Prime Minister, 19th Century
    duncan1890/Getty Images
    Seasonal work in the autumn garden concept. Fallen rotten and bad apples gardeners bury in deep pite hole
    vavlt/Getty Images
    Old picture of a family on summer vacations
    Shanina/Getty Images
    Adult woman portrait in 1934, black and white
    Lady-Photo/Getty Images
    Fashion history vector
    artbesouro/Getty Images
    Beautiful living room with fire place decorated for christmas
    RobertBreitpaul/Getty Images
    Family and child
    grynold/Getty Images
    Facade of Florence Cathedral
    alxpin/Getty Images
    Drawing sketch to become a real classic living room with a fireplace
    gamespirit/Getty Images
    Texture of old white concrete
    Xurzon/Getty Images
    Manhattan - New York City Map - vector illustration
    dikobraziy/Getty Images
    Business closeup of two hands exchanging dollars on grey background.
    KvitaJan/Getty Images
    Couple hands dancing waltz at ball
    O_Lypa/Getty Images
    young woman holding a white plate with pasta and cheese
    wernerimages/Getty Images
    Young couple in 1950
    Lady-Photo/Getty Images
    Handcuffed hands of arrested criminal man in black shirt and handcuffs
    Srdjanns74/Getty Images
    Italian women friends in 1934
    Lady-Photo/Getty Images
    New York mail stamps collection. Faded colored impress
    ChubarovY/Getty Images
    crucifix, jesus on the cross in church with ray of light from stained glass
    thanasus/Getty Images
    Wood table top on blurred of counter cafe shop with light bulb.Background for montage product display or design key visual
    HAKINMHAN/Getty Images
    Upper West Side brownstones with doorsteps. Manhattan, New York City
    francois-roux/Getty Images
    Antique photograph of World's famous sites: Commonwealth Avenue, Boston
    ilbusca/Getty Images
    Antique photograph of World's famous sites: President Harrison's House, Indianapolis
    ilbusca/Getty Images
    Work in progress on pipes
    georgeclerk/Getty Images
    Vector vintage car
    mechanick/Getty Images
    Antique photograph of World's famous sites: New York Broadway
    ilbusca/Getty Images
    Business man walk cycle
    D_A_S_H_U/Getty Images
    Antique photograph of World's famous sites: Longfellow's House, Cambridge, Massachusetts, US
    ilbusca/Getty Images
    Nurse standing seriously with her team
    Wavebreakmedia/Getty Images
    Glass half full or half emtpy of beer
    Peter Horrox/Getty Images
    Part of ten dollar bill American money
    Dmytro Synelnychenko/Getty Images
    Florence skyline
    Lisa-Blue/Getty Images
    Pennsylvania Avenue, Washington, D.C., United States, Antique American Photograph, 1893
    bauhaus1000/Getty Images
    Antique plate photo of 1920s businessman with glass of whiskey leaning against wall.
    ysbrandcosijn/Getty Images
    Police protective clothing
    grynold/Getty Images
    Antique London's photographs: The Admiralty
    ilbusca/Getty Images
    dirt frame overlay
    jakkapan21/Getty Images
    Pregnant woman with hands on her belly
    lolostock/Getty Images
    Magnificent bedroom for grand personalities
    KatarzynaBialasiewicz/Getty Images
    Liverpool, Lime Street, England in 1880s
    mashuk/Getty Images
    Witness interview at police station
    cyano66/Getty Images
    Grunge Black and White Distress Texture Background.
    ISMODE/Getty Images
    Retro Wedding
    DieterMeyrl/Getty Images
    Fifth Ave and West 33rd sign in New York City
    ViewApart/Getty Images
    mortuary slabs
    phildaintith/Getty Images
    Woman walking on cobblestone pavement road. Girl exploring new city wearing in shoes and skirt. Close-up view
    Vadim_Key/Getty Images
    Pensioner Reading Newspaper
    Aleksei_Ptitsa/Getty Images
    Perfect seascape
    hektor2/Getty Images

Comments • 9 112

  • Elunei
    Elunei  1 hours back

    I would HOPE that my parents would look for me at least for a year before giving up... but that’s just me

    • Caitlin Wallin
      Caitlin Wallin  2 hours back

      at 4:40 ryan says "private dicks" and i need to share this

      • Caitlin Wallin
        Caitlin Wallin  2 hours back

        those are both words for ,,,,,,,,,, penis parts

    • Madison Arthur
      Madison Arthur  6 hours back

      There’s a haunted hotel in Wichita Kansas. A man died there after jumping from his room. He was a piano player and people say he can here him crying and playing the piano.

      • The Little Tree
        The Little Tree  7 hours back

        Hi, yes, I’m Dorothy age 127

        • Bree Gwendolyn
          Bree Gwendolyn  9 hours back

          I still find it super suspicious that her parents wanted to end the investigation

          • Jada Rose Shawger
            Jada Rose Shawger  10 hours back

            "Where's that mole on your butt cheek?"

            • The Big Giant BOMB DOG
              The Big Giant BOMB DOG  15 hours back

              Next could you do the dissapearence of Lee Boxell?

              • jenna bonebrake
                jenna bonebrake  1 days back

                “No one was aware of any secret marriage”

                oh damn it’s almost like it was a secret marriage

                • miles latta
                  miles latta  1 days back

                  Do Madeline McCann

                  • Fred Krazé
                    Fred Krazé  1 days back

                    Doppelgangers are weird, i swear i saw a duplicate of my best friend from highschool who walked right past me on the sidewalk, they were even wearing the same kind of grey and blue sweater from his dads work, same light blue eyes, same small jaw with a big nose, same Osiris shoes i last saw him with a year before i moved 1k+ miles away........
                    They even had the same distinct stride, they took long strides with a noticeable left twist to their torso when they walked and their right foot was at an angle further out than normal, just like my friend.
                    As i was stopped on the sidewalk thinking my best friend was right in front of me staring in disbelief, they walked right past me giving me the (wtf is up with you?) kinda look and just kept walking.
                    The only thing that i don't remember is seeing his dads company's logo on the sweater, but as it is it was a dark grey logo half the circumference of your fist on a lighter grey background, which was a popular sweater design with a grey body and blue arm, you have likely seen one in the wild at one point or another.

                    • Fred Krazé
                      Fred Krazé  1 days back

                      "Chipmunk noises"
                      Okay, see you later!!!

                      • Fizza Zaidi
                        Fizza Zaidi  1 days back

                        Do the Disappearance of Madeleine Mccann

                        • Brianna Shimandle
                          Brianna Shimandle  2 days back

                          I wanna see you guys talk about the Marilyn Shepard Case!

                          • Jamile Gutierrez
                            Jamile Gutierrez  2 days back

                            Or maybe they took her out of the will just in case she was to come back with her new mans and killed her parents 🤔👀

                            • Paige Pflieger
                              Paige Pflieger  2 days back

                              technology was obviously not as advanced as it is today, so i feel like 4 1/2 months back then would kind of make the case unsolvable unless someone just brought dorothy to the police station with proof.

                              • Ninedaysjane
                                Ninedaysjane  2 days back

                                This show is so-so but God, the Asian guy's voice makes it intolerable.

                                • Cynical Liberal
                                  Cynical Liberal  2 days back

                                  Dorothy & Gladys sound like old ladies, but I guess old ladies had to be young sometime.

                                  • IamtheNight99
                                    IamtheNight99  2 days back

                                    The real mystery is why this is still legal:

                                    • Seraphim Hotker
                                      Seraphim Hotker  2 days back

                                      What if her brother kidnapped and murdered her to get a larger proportion of the will?

                                      • Lars Jankus
                                        Lars Jankus  2 days back

                                        It's been 2 years since I watched BuzzFeed

                                        • G Versace
                                          G Versace  2 days back

                                          love New York... there's never a dull moment here :)

                                          • Brandy Olmos
                                            Brandy Olmos  2 days back

                                            “ Donate to plan parenthood “haha

                                            • Waffle King
                                              Waffle King  2 days back

                                              Hey so I just found this out so I took a 23 and me test and I was part French so I was looking more and in my living room at my grandmas it was a picture of her and it said on the thing you’re related to Dorthy Arnold and I’m like HOLY SH*T so I told my mom and she flipped out and that is the whole story true 💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯 Oh and btw I’m American

                                              • julian thy bitch
                                                julian thy bitch  2 days back

                                                never knew I had a family member named dorthey

                                                • Me me
                                                  Me me  3 days back

                                                  Bless these men for their bit with Planned Parenthood

                                                  • Me me
                                                    Me me  3 days back

                                                    Keeping up with the Kardashanes

                                                    • Me me
                                                      Me me  3 days back

                                                      “Nancy Draw-up” y’all, this man 😂

                                                      • Knessen
                                                        Knessen  3 days back

                                                        Nah in New York you just see crack feens yelling on the subway and the occasional performers who don’t get any money and then the fake homeless people trying to get money.

                                                        • Maudie Icrochet
                                                          Maudie Icrochet  3 days back

                                                          I think George was Dorothy's gay friend and she shacked up with a bohemian artist.

                                                          • Jack Skellington
                                                            Jack Skellington  3 days back

                                                            High school boys, 4:17

                                                            • Sarah Cobarrubias
                                                              Sarah Cobarrubias  3 days back

                                                              “DB Cooper breaks silence to dunk on goul bois” 🤣🤣🤣

                                                              • Charlotte Beatty
                                                                Charlotte Beatty  3 days back

                                                                Dorothy Arnold: goes missing
                                                                the watcher: all me baby

                                                                • Ville Stenvall
                                                                  Ville Stenvall  3 days back

                                                                  Can you guys do the lake bodom murders.

                                                                  • Luna Monge
                                                                    Luna Monge  3 days back

                                                                    I’ve watched almost every single video...I need more.

                                                                    • Leah Bee Walker
                                                                      Leah Bee Walker  4 days back

                                                                      Why would they not hold her for ransom???

                                                                      • Leah Bee Walker
                                                                        Leah Bee Walker  4 days back

                                                                        I MISSED THIS VIDEO COME OUT AND NOW IM THRILLED IM HERE

                                                                        • CandyLover556
                                                                          CandyLover556  4 days back

                                                                          "i'd love to be an heiress"
                                                                          - same, shane, same

                                                                          • codemiesterbeats
                                                                            codemiesterbeats  4 days back

                                                                            cash is king bois...

                                                                            • codemiesterbeats
                                                                              codemiesterbeats  4 days back

                                                                              cash is king bois...

                                                                              • BeeLover90
                                                                                BeeLover90  4 days back

                                                                                That gossip girl reboot sounded good! I’d watch lol

                                                                                • Ivy Hoss
                                                                                  Ivy Hoss  4 days back

                                                                                  Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser Kaspar Hauser

                                                                                  You should do a video about Kaspar Hauser

                                                                                  • Michael Crippen
                                                                                    Michael Crippen  4 days back

                                                                                    You know what would be REALLY cool? If you guys would do AMITYVILLE!!

                                                                                    • Marina Munoz
                                                                                      Marina Munoz  5 days back

                                                                                      Abortion is wroooong!

                                                                                    • Spencer Evans
                                                                                      Spencer Evans  5 days back

                                                                                      You should do a case on Emmit till

                                                                                      • Ngaihzuali 16
                                                                                        Ngaihzuali 16  5 days back

                                                                                        Seriously??? Kardashanes ???? 🤣🤣

                                                                                        • alex
                                                                                          alex  5 days back

                                                                                          *Legend has it she's still looking for a gown...*

                                                                                          • Nicosarea
                                                                                            Nicosarea  5 days back

                                                                                            6:48 OOH! Shane, I'd recommend watching "A Place Further than the Universe"! It's a show about these high-school girls getting involved in an Antarctic expedition; "Spurred by her mother's disappearance, Shirase Kobuchizawa has been working hard to fund her trip to Antarctica. Despite facing doubt and ridicule from virtually everyone, Shirase is determined to embark on this expedition to search for her mother in a place further than the universe itself. "

                                                                                            • Julia Meade
                                                                                              Julia Meade  6 days back

                                                                                              No one:
                                                                                              Absolutely no one:
                                                                                              Ryan: *ITS TIME TO NANCY DRAW UP*